9 Best Crib Mattress Reviews of Nov, 2019

We’ve taken the time to browse and also test many crib mattresses to come up with the perfect set of products. Our specialists have invested a lot of time into coming up with a list of features you need to close in on to be sure you’ve made the best investment.

The first aspect you need to take into consideration is the firmness of the mattress. Great mattresses are stiff to keep the baby safe. Unlike normal mattresses, a crib mattress needs to be above average when it comes to stiffness. This way it will prevent the baby from sinking in the material thus leading to breathing problems during sleep.

The second thing you will get with a top end mattress is durability. For a mattress to be durable, you will have to make sure it comes with a thick cover. Usually, the best crib mattresses have multiple laminated layers of coating which incorporate nylon.

All the best crib mattresses are certified. The Consumer Product Safety Commission ensures customers the product is safe to use and that it meets certain quality standards.

The fourth thing you need to check for is proper ventilation. An excellent crib mattress will have several reinforced holes on the sides to permit air flow. This will be of much help because it will not allow certain smells to set in.

#1. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress Review

If you are looking for a budget crib mattress, this is the perfect choice for you. Some top end products can be really expensive, and many people are unable to afford them. Even so, that does not mean their baby cannot be just as safe as a baby sleeping on a $$$ crib mattress. The Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is a perfect choice if you have less than $ to spend. It is the best crib mattress 2014 within its market range. It comes with firm support for your baby. The dense bonded fibers which construct the core will make sure your loved one sleeps safe and sound. It even has a hypoallergenic surface which is made without any toxic materials. It is very resistant to abuse, and it has no problem repelling substances which may stain. It can easily be cleaned because it is waterproof. It is also certified and meets FFS without incorporating chemicals. Even though it represents the less expensive alternative, the Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress is durable. It will last for as long as you need it to.Buy From Amazon

2. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Review

Sealy Baby Soybean Foam-Core Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress - Lightweight Hypoallergenic Soy Foam, Design Pattern May Vary, 51.63" x 27.25"

This mattress features a soy-based high-density foam core. It has square corners for a good fit and a water-resistant covering. It’s also pretty lightweight and has a lock-stitched binding for durability.

This natural fiber mattress is nice if you’re looking for something environment-friendly. This natural foam core mattress is also a practical choice given the secure binding and the $$ price tag.Buy From Amazon


3. My First Mattress Memory Foam Crib Mattress Review

My First Crib Mattress, Breathable Memory Foam Crib Mattress with Removable Protective Waterproof Cover, Plush, and Hypoallergenic

This crib mattress has all the right features to become a strong candidate for the title of best crib mattress 2014. It will handle all your baby’s needs regarding comfort. It is one of the safest out there because of the high-density foam which will support your child while he is asleep. It is also hypoallergenic, phthalate-free and mite proof so it will last for a long time without becoming a health hazard to your baby. It meets CPSC and ASTM standards, and it can be used with a toddler bed. It has a washable cover made out of 100% polyester soft velour. One of the best things about My First Mattress products is that they can be paired with all sorts of accessories. You will be able to purchase things like memory foam pillows and much more all at once, thus sparing you a lot of time.Buy From Amazon

4. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier, Ecru

Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Orthopedic Style Crib Mattress | Eco-Friendly Foam with Ultra-Soft Organic Waterproof Hypoallergenic Cotton Cover - 51.63" x 27.25" x 6"

This is an orthopedic foam mattress with dual firmness. It’s GREENGUARD certified and comes with an organic cotton cover with waterproof backing.
This is the number one mattress for the working mom. It has everything you could wish for in a crib mattress. It’s from Colgate, the top crib mattress brand in the US, and earth-friendly to boot. At $$, you get the comfort of organic cotton for your baby without breaking the bank.

[su_spoiler title=”Read More” style=”fancy” icon=”arrow”]

A Review of the Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress in Ecru

As a parent, you know how important it is for your child to get a good night’s sleep. In the first year of life and even beyond, adequate rest is essential to give him all the advantages of a well-developed mind and body. That’s why it’s essential to buy the right crib mattress for him. A good crib mattress is firm, fits your crib well, and above all, provides a healthy sleeping environment for your baby. The Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier crib mattress in Ecru can provide you with these basic requirements, and perhaps even a little bit more.

Trusted Brand

When it comes to crib mattresses, there are a few brands out there that come highly recommended in parents’ guides and other types of literature that help you buy only the best and safest products for your baby. You’ll find that Colgate is considered one of the oldest and most highly-regarded makers of crib mattresses on the market today. It is particularly well-known for creating nice, firm mattresses that help reduce the risk of SIDS. The Colgate Eco Classica III has the same features that make Colgate mattresses a favorite with parents and healthcare providers alike, but with a few improvements that make it even safer for your baby and earth-friendly as well.

Standard Dimensions

Size is a rather big deal when you’re talking about crib mattresses. In fact, it’s probably a good idea to read a lot of product reviews like this one or go to the store to check out the goods if you’re shopping for crib mattresses and cribs. That’s because your mattress and crib should be the perfect fit. The mattress lies snugly in your crib with little or no space between it and the sides – you should be able to squeeze no more than a couple of fingers between the mattress and crib.
A crib mattress that’s got a loose fit could catch your little one’s hands and feet, making it a safety risk. Fortunately, the Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier crib mattress in Ecru is made to fit all standard-sized cribs and comes with square corners that make for a snugger fit. Plus, with an overall thickness of 6 inches, you can be sure that your crib sheets will fit tightly over the mattress, so they don’t pose a suffocation hazard.

Light Weight

This mattress weights just over 9 pounds – that means it’s only slightly heavier than your newborn. That’s good news, as you can look forward to being able to change sheets without a struggle. You can also turn this mattress over or move it from one place to another without a fuss.

Baby-Friendly and Earth-Friendly Core

Of course, one of the biggest reasons to consider this crib are the promises the manufacturer makes of this crib being both earth-friendly and baby-friendly. In recent years, it has been discovered that ordinary polyurethane foam mattresses contain chemical fire-retardants that release volatile organic compounds into the air over time. These same VOCs are believed to cause developmental problems in small children. Thus, many parents are seeking healthier alternatives to regular foam mattresses. The Colgate Eco Classic III, Dual Firmness model, satisfies the toughest Greenguard standards, covering up to 10,000 of these VOCs.
You’ll notice the difference when you remove the wrappings on this crib mattress – you’ll discover that it doesn’t have that scary, synthetic chemical smell. That’s because this mattress’s core is made with Certi-PUR-US certified ecologically friendlier foam, which is manufactured using plant oils.

Dual Firmness

If you’re a practical parent, you’ll also be glad to know that buying his mattress is like getting two crib mattresses in one. It’s got a different level of firmness on each of its sides, which means that you’ll be getting the firmness that’s necessary to protect your infant from SIDS and providing him with the softness and comfort that he needs to sleep soundly when he’s older. You’ll have peace of mind regarding his health and safety while he’s still at a high-risk age for SIDS, but you won’t have to get a new mattress when he’s older and requires a snugglier sleeping surface after a long and tiring day of play and exploration.

Waterproof organic cotton cover

Finally, the last but not the least important feature of the Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness crib mattress is its waterproof organic cotton cover. This cover gives you all the benefits of organic cottons, such as comfort and breathability. It’s also got a waterproof layer farther down that keeps the core of the mattress safe from dirt and damp.[/su_spoiler]

Buy From Amazon

5. Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress Reviews

Sealy Baby Firm Rest Waterproof Standard Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress - 204 Premium Coils, Luxury Design Pattern May Vary, 51.7" x 27.3"

The Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress is one of the smartest investments you could make. It offers great value for money while still providing the absolute best safety features. It is just as firm as it should be because of the soy-based foam stuffed between the stain resistant covers. It will reduce sagging to a minimum, and it will stay firm for years. It can take a lot of abuse, and it can be easily cleaned by using a wet cloth. Because it is a wet-resistant crib mattress, allergens will have a hard time sticking to its surface. The body of the mattress is very lightweight and easy to handle. It meets CPSIA standards, and it is nicely ventilated because of the special airflow pocket it incorporates. It is made in the US which guarantees you get a quality product which is safe for your baby.

The quality of a crib mattress plays a crucial role in enhancing a baby’s safety and quality of his or her sleep. Crib mattresses come in handy in the market and from different brands. Even so, only the best will offer comfort and safety for your kid.[su_spoiler title=”Read More” style=”fancy” icon=”arrow”]

The Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress is an exclusive mattress that comes with lots of features, which are specifically engineered to promote quality sleep. It is phthalate and flammability compliant. Also, it is made of high-quality nontoxic materials and has nonallergenic sleeping layers which protect the kid from allergic reactions. Remember the baby’s skin is always tender and sensitive and has to be efficiently protected. The layers also offer support, comfort, and firmness.
The Sealy Baby Firm Rest Crib Mattress also has all-around heavy steel border rids which provides corner, edge, and maximum side support. It also features innerspring coils for long-lasting strength and support since they are heat tempered. The baby’s weight is evenly distributed all over the entire mattress to prevent discomforts while sleeping.

It is a great crib mattress that comes shipped standard with an included 20-year warranty. Therefore, it is economical and saves a great deal of cash.

Similarly, it is a high-quality product that comes with a STAPH-GARD reinforced laminate cover to provide antibacterial protection. The baby, therefore, can sleep in comfortably with all-round protection.

Its antistatic surface is designed in a way that resists daily wear and tear elements. What’s more, it is easy to maintain because the antistatic surface also resists moisture, mildew, and stains. You only have to wipe it clean with a soft damp cloth when cleaning. The mattress provides the best sleep environment for the kid because it will never produce any bad odor like other brands. To complete it, it is a phenomenal crib mattress that remains firm even after two or four kids have slept on it.[/su_spoiler]Buy From Amazon

6. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Crib Mattress Review

The Little Dreamer is one great mattress. It comes with an affordable price tag, but it provides all the necessary safety features your baby needs to sleep comfortably. If you are looking for an economical product which is currently advertised as the safest of its market range, this is the item to purchase. It not only provides a safe sleeping environment but it is also comfortable because of the foam which fills its interior. It can be used either on the infant side or the toddler side. It also uses materials which are not toxic at all, and it is one of the most durable on the market. The Little Dreamer by Moonlight Slumber comes with CertiPUR certification. It is also waterproof, hypoallergenic and treated with innovative antimicrobial protection. Last but not least, it can be easily cleaned with a wet sponge. One other thing you might like about this particular product is its design. It somehow manages to make the baby’s bed look more elegant.Buy From Amazon

7. Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Crib Mattress Review

Manufacturers advertise the Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers as a luxury product. They might be right if you consider the excellent features you will get with this mattress. It has one of the highest coil counts on the market which makes it one of the safest and most comfortable products of its kind. The manufacturers have emphasized on safety, providing parents with the bonus of reinforced border protection and the innovative Innofoam corner guards which offer incredible stability no matter how big the stress. The materials used are also pretty amazing. The natural cotton used to wrap the mattress uses no chemicals and has no toxic component whatsoever. It is even fire and waterproof. The whole thing is stain resistant which is pretty essential for a crib mattress. It can be used for both toddlers and babies. All you have to do is flip it on the right side. It is CertiPUR-US approved, and also GREENGUARD GOLD approved. One last thing you might be interested in is the fact that this crib mattress is properly ventilated. The vents placed on each side will keep it fresh and smell nice for many years.Buy From Amazon

8. Naturepedic No Compromise Organic Crib Mattress Review

This is a top end crib mattress. It is made of 100% organic cotton which is something you don’t see in many other similar products. It is the perfect mattress to buy if you want your child to be comfortable and most importantly, safe. It has a 150 coil count which combined with the certified organic cotton creates the feeling of elegance. It has a waterproof surface which will come in very handy when having to deal with inevitable food spills. Because it is waterproof, it will also keep moisture out thus maintaining its initial state for a long time. Even though you will only have it around for a few years, there is no point compromising the comfort and safety of your baby just to save a few extra dollars. With the Naturepedic crib mattress, you will find two usable sides. One for the toddler period and the other for the infant period. Both sides are built differently to meet the needs of a particular age range. We suggest making an effort to buy this product mostly because it is truly one of the healthiest out there. It does not get better than this if you are looking for a chemical-free crib mattress.Buy From Amazon

9. Colgate Classica III Foam Crib Mattress Reviews

Colgate Classica III Crib Mattress | 51.6"L x 27.2"W x 5"H | Dual Firmness | Orthopedic Lightweight Foam Mattress With Triple Layered Reinforced, Waterproof Crib Cover | Made in the USA

The Colgate Classica III Foam Crib Mattress is our top pick for the best crib mattress that is now available for purchase. This is an orthopedic style mattress with 5 inches of thick dual firmness to provide optimal comfort for your loved little ones. It’s made with a tear-resistant and water resistant vinyl cover that provides you with added durability to ensure you will be able to keep it in excellent condition for the life of your ownership.

Buy From Amazon

Buying a Used Crib Mattress to Save Money

Having a baby can be an expensive time. Most parents don’t have thousands of dollars to spend on all of the gear required for the child and are trying to find ways to lower the cost of the baby gear required, choosing previously used items can be a great way to save, as parents can find popular baby items and nursery gear for less than fifty percent of the original cost of the items being purchased.

Using the online classified ads and even the popular baby consignment stores in the local area can be a great place to start looking for a crib mattress. These places have a variety of brands, and crib mattresses that are suited to a variety of budgets.

Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II Crib MattressA great idea to save money, a used crib mattress can be a great idea to stretch the budget. However, there are certain things that the parent should consider when buying a used crib mattress.

Factors that should be considered before buying the use crib mattress include:


Parents should ensure that the used crib mattress being purchased is purchased from a non-smoking, non-pet home to avoid allergens being attached to the mattress. Parents should inspect the mattress and ensure that it’s free from stains, dust-mites, and evidence that the mattress has been exposed to bed bugs.


Parents should consider the model of the mattress, the age of the mattress and the brand and model number to ensure that the mattress is going to be safe for the infant sleeping on the mattress. Using the model and brand information can allow the parent to simply enter the information online, to determine whether there have been any recalls that may affect the safety of the mattress.


Parents should consider the age of the mattress that is being purchased. After five to seven years, the fibers and components of the mattress that provide support can begin to break-down, causing the support to suffer and reduce the safety of the mattress.

Using these factors, customers purchasing used crib mattresses can ensure that they are getting a safe crib mattress that’s also budget friendly.

Preventing SIDS with a Proper Crib Mattress

Crib mattresses are one of essential safety items that are going to be used in the nursery. Choosing the right crib mattress can ensure that the child is going to remain safe while sleeping in the crib – and give the parent peace of mind while the child is sleeping.

Though there has been no confirmed correlation between SIDS (Sudden Infant Death Syndrome) and the choice of crib mattress used in the nursery, there are some features of the crib mattresses that should be chosen to ensure the safety of the infant.

Choose a Firm Mattress

Two types of crib mattresses are available – firm and soft mattresses. Firm crib mattresses can ensure that the child remains safe while sleeping as they are not going to get that feeling of ‘sinking into’ the mattress. Infants that are unable to turn over pose the risk of suffocating in the mattress.

Choose a Supportive Mattress

Crib mattresses should not only be supportive throughout the depth of the mattress but should ensure that there is support throughout the edges of the mattress. Reinforced edges of the mattress will avoid the infant from becoming stuck between the crib and the mattress, reducing one of the biggest risks of infants sleeping in cribs.

Choose Organic Crib Mattresses

Organic crib mattresses do not contain the potentially harmful chemicals that are found in traditional crib mattresses. Throughout the manufacturing process, there are chemicals that are left on the mattress. There has been some thought that the chemicals on these mattresses can increase the chances of infants suffering from SIDS.

Choosing an organic crib mattress eradicates these chemicals and can be an effective way to provide a safe sleeping environment that is not going to become absorbed through the skin, and through the lungs of the infant.

The more you are aware of SIDS, the more prepared you are going to be as a parent. Do your research and make sure that you only buy the safest crib mattress that you can find.


Choosing a Baby Crib Mattress

Choices, choices, choices… they seem to be everywhere. Sometimes we have so many options to choose from that it’s difficult to come to any definitive decision. That’s even true in something as mundane as purchasing a baby crib mattress for your new nursery. But your choice is important because it will affect the life of your baby for some time.

So what’s the key to choosing a baby crib mattress properly? Knowledge!

The more knowledge you have concerning construction methods, materials used, features, and sizes, the better equipped you will be to decide what is best for your child. We’ll endeavor to give you some valuable information in the following paragraphs that will hopefully facilitate your choice. If you’re still unsure about crib mattresses after reading this article, please don’t hesitate to do further research. And don’t ever forget to ask friends and family members for their advice. Their experience in raising their children is invaluable.

Crib Mattress Sizes

Of all the mattress choices you’ll have to make, this one is perhaps the easiest. As a general rule, you’ll probably find that there are no definitive standards as far as crib mattress sizes go. But you’ll also find that most baby mattresses fall within specified parameters. To determine the size you need, simply measure the interior of the crib from head to toe and side rail to side rail. Make sure you take interior measurements NOT exterior measurements.

Once you do have a mattress for your crib, you need to check its size by using the finger test. Center the mattress so that there’s an equal amount of clearance all way around, then try to slip some fingers between the edge of the mattress and the sides of the crib. If you can get two or more fingers comfortably into the open space, your mattresses are too small. One finger or less means you have a properly fitting mattress.

Inner Spring Crib Mattresses

Inner spring mattresses have been the standard in the United States for decades. They tend to hold up well against all sorts of punishment, and they provide a decent amount of support across the entire sleep surface. When purchasing an innerspring mattress for a crib, it’s important that you note two characteristics:

  • Coil Count – Coil count tells you how many springs are in the mattress. Obviously, the higher the number, the more support the mattress will provide for your baby. Ideally, you should be looking for something in the 125 to 150 range. Mattresses with smaller coil counts don’t provide as much support and can cause problems later on.
  • Coil Gauge – Coil gauge is a measurement of the thickness of an individual spring’s diameter. In contrast to coil count, you’re looking for a lower number. The lower the number, the thicker the springs, and the more support they provide. For maximum durability and support, you should probably be looking for something gauged at 15 or lower.

Some advantages of the innerspring mattress include a lower price, excellent durability, and a lower risk of suffocation issues. Disadvantages include the possibility of toxic chemicals leaching off, the potential for allergy issues, and decreased discomfort as the mattress breaks down.

Foam Crib Mattresses

Foam mattresses have been used in baby cribs for a couple of decades now. They are gaining in popularity as more and more parents are figuring out from their beds how comfortable foam can be. Typically you can choose between natural latex foam and synthetic latex foam, although finding baby crib mattresses made from synthetic latex is becoming harder and harder. Synthetic latex tends to incorporate petroleum products, which very few mattress manufacturers are willing to use in a baby mattress.

That leaves us basically with a choice between Talalay latex and Dunlop latex. Both types of latex are usually made primarily from natural latex rubber. The only difference between the two is the manufacturing process. Talalay latex tends to be softer and more forgiving, thereby making it inappropriate for parents who are concerned about suffocation issues. Dunlop latex, although it is more rigid, tends to be much more firm and supportive. Proponents of latex mattresses for babies tend to prefer Dunlop latex over Talalay.

Some of the advantages of using a latex foam baby crib mattress include:

  • few or no toxic chemicals present
  • better fit in the crib
  • the lower tendency for allergy issues
  • lower risk of fire

Organic Baby Crib Mattresses

The last thing you need to know involves organic baby crib mattresses. Ever since the environmental movement gained steam in the 1980s production of organic mattresses has picked up. Proponents of these mattresses claim that going organic does several things including:

protecting your child from toxic chemicals
preventing the growth of bacteria as a result of urination
lowering the risk of childhood allergies
helping protect the environment

It’s important to know if you’re considering purchasing an organic mattress, which there are no clear industry standards as to what qualifies as truly organic. And although federal regulations prohibit product manufacturers from using purposely deceptive marketing language, the law is ambiguous enough to allow a claim of organic when it may not necessarily be so. The only way for you to know for sure whether or not a mattress is truly organic is to read the label. If you’re still unsure, ask a salesman for literature that proves the manufacturer’s organic claims.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *